
TiVo will change the way you watch TV. Unless you’ve already owned a DVR, in which case you might not be that impressed.
Our living room is now home to a TiVo HD DVR after we upgraded from our old Humax PVR 8000T. Having played with the TiVo for a few days now, I’ve concluded a few things. Firstly, there is not much on offer on the HD channels, but secondly and more importantly, there are some flaws with the TiVo.
- It’s too polite, always asking you to confirm actions. A task that might involve one press of a button (like stopping recording) takes two or three. I can’t really speak for other devices, but the Humax is easier to use. Of course we are more used to what we know, but the Humax is a simpler device with a better remote control and more efficient actions.
- It’s always on and you can’t turn it off. I don’t know what the TiVo consumes in terms of power, but it must do so 24×7.
- There’s no volume control in terms of the audio output from the unit. You can set the remote control to set the volume on the TV, but that means controlling two devices with one remote and thus pointing it in two different places. Not a huge issue, I suppose.
- There’s no clock on the front panel. This may not be a big deal for many people, but the Humax had a digital clock on the front that was always on and it became very convenient.
- There’s quite a bit of screen flicker when the program resolution changes. For example a program is broadcast in full HD (1080i) but then you change channels to a SD broadcast, if the TiVo is in certain modes, the screen will flicker or go blank for a moment whilst it changes over. (We solve this by having a fixed output of 720p since our current TV doesn’t do 1080i anyway).
- Similarly, the volume fluctuates. At first I thought this was due to the change over between the 5.1 channel audio in HD programming and the 2 channel stereo of SD programming, but it happens during programs. Could be the TV but it’s never done that before.
- It’s a bit big and ugly, the thing looks more like a small desktop PC rather than a slick piece of entertainment kit. The Humax on the other hand is a nice slim, silver and mirror unit.
On the positive side, and the main reason I chose the TiVo over other choices, is the “Find Programs” functionality:
- Search by title allows you to choose a show by name and it will be recorded, without really having to worry about channel, date, time, duration.
- Wishlist Search allows you to find shows by searching for actor, category or general keyword. Doesn’t sound like much in this Web 2.0 age, but it’s pretty good for TV.
- Season Pass allows you to select a show and record all instances of it automatically, week after week or whatever frequency it’s on. If it changes timeslot or day (even channel?) it will still be recorded.
- TiVo Suggestions allows you to rate shows you watch or record using a thumbs up/down system and based on this other shows you might like are suggested.
Browsing what’s on all channels using the “Guide” button is also well done; it’s similar to Foxtel and better than the Humax. Eventually we’ll run out of space, so being able to pull content off onto a computer and burn it or store it is a great feature, or we can extend the TiVo’s capacity via an external eSata disk (strangely you can use USB disks even though there are two USB ports).
So why the upgrade? The Humax did change the way we watch TV, and we quickly got used to being able to pause TV—say if your wee baby starts crying and you don’t want to miss that all important cliffhanger ending!—or rewinding a bit to watch something again. And of course, just like VCRs before them, Digital Video Recorders are great for recording your favourite shows (but unlike a VCR most DVRs are pretty easy to program).
But almost as quickly as we got to like the Humax, we started to outgrow it. When we bought it, there were a few twin-tuner models around, but they were very expensive and we reasoned that the need for two tuners would rarely come up. How wrong we were. We constantly ran into situations where we wanted to record something on one channel and watch/record something on another channel. It was really frustrating to have to switch to the TV’s analogue tuner to watch the other channel and to not be able to record it. There was also quite a lot of deleting shows from our almost full hard disk, as we couldn’t get any content off the device.
So it was time to upgrade, something which I’ve rarely had a genuine need to do. Of course there are times when you upgrade because you want a bigger/better/newer model but this was something we use a lot and there was a real unmet need. Thus, top of the wish-list was twin-tuners and the ability to get content off (either via USB or network). There have also been lots of ads for the High Definition channels from the free-to-air networks, so that was something we thought we should put on the list too.
What to buy? Well of course there was Topfield, which from the early days of DVRs was a leading name with features and price far better than what the usual brands offer. In recent years they have copped a bit of criticism for bugs but the new TF7100HDPVRt was definitely a contender. It’s got a big drive, full twin-tuner capability and wifi networking. Combined with Ice TV you get the ability to record shows based on their name, rather than a fixed date/time/duration. You see, the problem with a VCR-style scheduled recording is that shows run over time, under time and get moved between timeslots and even days. So your scheduled recordings can miss the start, end or entire length of the show you wanted. By taking ‘up to date’ programming data from the networks, the Ice TV service provides selected DVRs with a proper EPG (Electronic Program Guide) that you can actually use, as opposed to the guides actually published/broadcast by the networks which are inaccurate and unreliable.
There is of course another player who is renowned for this human friendly recording, the US smash-hit TiVo, which until now was not officially available in Australia. Their latest generation DVR has similar features to the Topfield, is similarly priced but with a reputation for usability. Even though the on-paper comparison might seem to suggest the Topfield 7100 is a better bet (bigger hard disk, longer ‘live pause’, full twin-tuner features) I decided on the TiVo pretty much based on the virtues of its integrated EPG service, which downloads current programming data from the web. The proposition is that, as part of the deal with the 7 network that brought TiVo to Australia, the programming data will be more accurate. So far it seems to be.
Overall, I am happy with the TiVo. It performs the main function we bought it for (recording or watching multiple channels simultaneously) and the “Find Programs” features are really worth shouting about—would help if there was more quality content on free-to-air though! But there are definitely areas for improvement.
And I will have to never ever look at that new Topfield lest I regret my decision :)